There is debate whether or not jude was actually quoting the apocraphal book of enoch or something else. The part included in both jude and 1 enoch is poetic and possibly related to a true prophetic oral tradition. Enoch contains unique material on the origins of demons and giants, why some angels fell from heaven, an explanation of why the great flood was morally necessary, and prophetic exposition of the. Jude 9, 1415 why does jude quote the assumption of moses. And behold there was another habitation more spacious than the former, every entrance to which was open before me, erected in the midst of a vibrating flame. So greatly did it excel in all points, in glory, in magnificence, and in magnitude, that it is impossible to describe to.
And then in verse 14 and 15 he mentions enoch and quotes from the book of enoch. The nt book of jude references the book of enoch and the nephilim which in hebrew means fallen ones. I first heard about the book of enoch a few years ago, while i was. A bornagain christian who has been reading the bible for several years only needs to read the book of enoch briefly to know that something is very wrong. The case against the book of first enoch a modern guide to.
However, other writers, arguing that jude 18 quotes 2 peter 3. While it only covers the first four verses of genesis 6 also refer to genesis 3. About 300 bc, the jewish group called the sadducees removed from the tenach old testament, the book of enoch. The implications of judes use of 1 enoch the doc file. And remember, jude like all of the other bible writers, was under the influence of the holy spirit when he included the quote from enoch. Jude quoting from the book of enoch does not indicate the entire book of enoch is inspired, or even true.
A passage quite similar to this is found in the apocryphal book of enoch. If indeed this is the case, then the prophecy of enoch was passed down by word of mouth accurately for over 2500 years. Neither of these books are canonical inspired scripture. Those of us who understand that the ot and nt are gods word then have to take. Apologetics press did jude treat noncanonical writings.
And its jam packed with the kind of theology that was circulating in the 2nd and 1st century bc. This quote in jude was a prophecy written by enoch about the final judgement of all mankind. Enoch walked with god and he was not for god took him. Jude 14 and about these also enoch, in the seventh generation from adam, prophesied, saying, behold, the lord came with many thousands of his holy ones jude 14. Both versions, of which copied manuscripts have been found mostly in greek and latin translations. Certain portions of the book, however, are of later date. See, the lord is coming with thousands upon thousands of his holy ones to judge everyone, and to convict all the ungodly of all the ungodly acts they have done in the ungodly way, and of all the harsh words ungodly sinners have spoken against him. That would explain why jude attributed the statement to enoch rather than the book by that name. Its reliability is attested to by the fact that jude wrote under divine inspiration. Enoch was a important person mentioned in genesis 5. Book of enoch was handed down to him from the time when he began to associate with superterrestrial beings. Could you comment on the prophecy of enoch, as mentioned in the book of jude vs. In fact, we are able to find a list with names of 18 prefect angels out of a total of 200 who committed the great sin. Critics argue that either jude believed these books were scripture, or the book of.
Some have suggested that jude quoted his prophecy from this source and thus the book of enoch was inspired. Did jude quote from the book of enoch let us reason. The book of enoch is an ancient composition known from two sets of versions, an ethiopic one that scholars identify as 1 enoch, and a slavonic version that is identified as 2 enoch, and which is also known as the book of the secrets of enoch. Judes quotation of enoch protestant reformed churches. And enoch also, the seventh from adam, enoch the seventh from adam is a quote from the book of enoch, not from the bible prophesied of these, saying, behold, the lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints, to execute judgment upon all, and to convince all that are ungodly among them of all their ungodly deeds which they have. And then enoch disappeared and none of the sons of men knew where he was hidden, where he was, or what had happened.
There is a jewish book called the assumption of moses written between the old. The earliest literature of the socalled church fathers is filled with references to this mysterious book. And enoch also, the seventh from adam, prophesied of these, saying, behold, the lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints, 15. The book of enoch is a very dangerous book, because it contradicts scripture, lies about the biblical cosmology, it declares hate for gods temple and perverts gods mercy and plan of salvation. The case against the book of first enoch a modern guide. The book of the watchers, which is the first part of the book of enoch and tells the story of the fallen angels, is thought to have been written approximately 300 years prior to the new testament. So greatly did it excel in all points, in glory, in magnificence, and in magnitude, that it is impossible to describe to you either the splendour or the extent of it. Book of enoch was handed down to him from the time when he began to associate with superterrestrial beings the existence of such a book of enoch, made certain from these numerous quotations, was the source of considerable perplexity and anxiety to christian theologians, and numerous and curious were the. Then in 1773, james bruce brought three copies back from ethiopia, having spent some years exploring the country. Enoch walked with god in an ungodly world watchtower online.
Not only that, but in true talmud tobe tradition, it contains theology at variance with that in the tanakh old testament, not to mention the messianic scriptures new. The existence of such a bo ok does not, however, rest on. In it enoch receives a series of revelations that are called parables. Thus, the new testament writers probably were quite familiar with the book of. But even if jude was quoting it, that wouldnt indicate a blanket endorsement of the book. Knibbs scholarly translation of the ethiopian manuscripts, the ethiopic book of enoch, oxford university press, which i believe to be the best translation currently available. But there is every reason to believe that it belongs to the second century b. The book of enoch was extant centuries before the birth of christ and yet is considered by many to be more christian in its theology than jewish. I have read enoch and it does appear that enoch and jude 14,15 are identical. By quoting enoch, jude indirectly quotes the passages to which the book of enoch alludes. Because this epistle is much shorter than 2 peter, and due to various stylistic details, some writers consider jude the source for the similar passages of 2 peter.
On this account i would trust the form of the poetry included in jude over that included in 1 enoch, when they differ. This debate aside, if this is a quote from the book of enoch, it does not. The book was quoted in the apocryphal book of baruch, and in several early church manuscripts. The term son of man is used 18 times in the book of enoch see the following examples. Jan 02, 2020 the same is true with jude, verses 1415. Book of enoch and noah enoch lived three hundred sixtyfive years. There was an oral tradition that enoch had given this prophecy, though it was not ever written down in the old testament scriptures. For jude, is he quoting 1 enoch or simply the same tradition upon which 1 enoch is based. If the writer of the book of enoch had access to an ancient source of this kind, why should we deny it to jude.
The book of enoch 5 the history of the book of enoch the book was thought to have been lost, for over 2,000 years, with many ancient sources referring to it, and even quoting parts, but no complete copies were known. Book of enoch explained everything explained today. Even if jude had quoted from the book of enoch that would not establish the inspiration of the latter work. The book of enoch claims to be written by enoch 7th from adam, but this is false. The book of enoch is one of those books that almost made it into the bible but was then rejected as apocryphal, even though enoch and the book itself are mentioned and referred to several times in the bible. How jude received the information about enochs message to the ungodly is a minor matter. The pharisees and disciples were familiar with this terminology and knew it referred to the anointed one of god. The apocrypha and the book of jude what do the scriptures say. Jude is not quoting the book of enoch sanderson1611.
All that is necessarily implied in jude 1415 is that enochs prediction happened to be descriptive of the men about whom jude wrote barnes, 1949, p. However, as already mentioned, its said that instead of quoting enochthe seventhfromadam, jude is actually quoting from the book of enoch. Is the book of enoch really a lost book of the bible. Book of enoch mentioned by jude baptist christian forums. If jude were quoting from the book of enoch, jude would have to had sourced two different books within the book of enoch, because there is not a single statement in the book of enoch that matches the entire statement of the book of jude 100%. Did jude quote from the book of enoch, is this a reliable book. It is interesting to note that no scholars believe the book of enoch to have truly been written by the enoch in the bible. The first aspect concerns whether or not jude 1415 is a quotation of an apocryphal writing called the book of enoch. If this is a quote from the book of enoch, it does not affect the doctrine of inspiration nor does it mean that the early church removed the book of enoch because of its internal inconsistencies. Although the quotation of 1 enoch in jude 1415 is often noted, the. This is important because here we have the only place in the bible that clearly affirms enochs account. Enoch walked with god in an ungodly world watchtower.
The book of enoch is considered to have been written by enoch, the seventh from adam. Jude 1415a it was also about these men that enoch, in the seventh generation from adam, prophesied, saying, behold, the lord came with many thousands of his holy ones, 15 to execute judgment upon all. Filled with hallucinatory visions of heaven and hell, angels and devils, enoch introduced concepts such as fallen angels, the appearance of a messiah, resurrection, a final judgement, and a. When jesus called himself the son of man, the pharisees understood exactly what it meant. Dec 31, 2008 for jude, is he quoting 1 enoch or simply the same tradition upon which 1 enoch is based. Further, jude did not necessarily imply that enoch saw into the future to predict attitudes or actions of the sinners under consideration in the epistle. Book of enoch, removed from the torah quranic warners. The point here is that jude does not simply snatch a convenient text from a noncanonical book in order to build his case. Jude 9, 1415 why does jude quote the assumption of. Thus, the new testament writers probably were quite familiar with the book of enoch, and it was even referenced in jude 1.
The book of enoch wasnt written until several thousand years later. What is the book of enoch and should it be in the bible. Jude, gateway to revelation conclusion grace thru faith. Enoch walked with god and he was not for god took him genesis 5. We should note that this reference in jude to the prophecy of enoch does not agree fully with any passage in the book of enoch, and is likely not a quotation from any book. The books of enoch were written by an unknown author thousands of years after enoch left the earth and were found to be theologically and historically inaccurate. After the birth of methuselah at 65, he lived 300 more years. Rather, in quoting from the book of enoch, he affirms the old testament texts from which the book is drawn.
An attempt has been made by some to bring the composition of the book down to christian times, so that enoch should quote jude, not jude enoch. Jude was very specific in identifying enoch as belonging to the seventh generation after adam. The book of enoch 1 enoch is not a small book and consists of 108 chapters. And he applies enoch s prophecy about false teachers in the last days to interlopers in the first century. It is generally believed that the apostles and the writers of the new testament were fully aware of the book of enoch also called 1 enoch. Jude quotes directly from the book of enoch, part of the scripture of the ethiopian and eritrean churches but. The book of enoch as the background to 1 peter, 2 peter, and jude.
For it is scarcely possible to deny that it is the work of more. While the book is fascinating to read, it is important to note that the first book of enoch is not scripture. Enoch gtr, lxx, htr is the name of four biblical persons. Jude could have had confirmation from the holy spirit that the original enoch actually said what jude had written. Feb 05, 2016 jude is not quoting the book of enoch sanderson1611. A nd enoch also, the seventh from adam, prophesied of these, saying, behold, the lord cometh with ten thousands of his saints, to execute judgment upon all, and to convince all that are ungodly among them of all their ungodly deeds which they have ungodly committed, and of all their hard speeches which ungodly sinners have spoken against him jude 1. The case against the book of first enoch hi im guy malone and im paradox brown and we are both known in the past as proponents, to one extent or another, of the book of 1st enoch, and of accepting it as probably inspired by god, and to some extent possibly useful for doctrine. Apologetics press did jude treat noncanonical writings as.
Tucked between the two oldest parts of 1 enoch is an apocalypse that goes under the name the similitudes or parables of enoch. The book of enoch jesus quoted it and so did apostles. By faith, enoch was taken so he would not see death, and he was not found on earth because god translated him. The words the seventh from adam may be also found in the same book enoch 60. It is considered an apocryphal book as well as a part of the pseudepigrapha literally means falsely ascribed is a collection of works supposedly written by a biblical character, although it is not a part of the canonical apocrypha. Jude further seems to agree with the the enoch account. First, the nt repeatedly quotes nonbiblical sources as truthful. The book of enoch, written during the second century b. Was jude quoting from the apocryphal book of enoch. So, jude quotes enoch, the seventh generation from adam. Why does the new testament cite extrabiblical sources. Book of enoch read online or download the book of enoch pdf.
Jude cites in his above quoted letter is almost verbatim from the ethiopic version of the book of enoch enoch 1. The pseudepigrapha book of first enoch or the apocalypse of enoch as it is sometimes called or second enoch may indeed contain the material found in jude verses 14 and 15. Jude 9, 1415 why does jude quote the assumption of moses v. The evidence shows that not only does the new testament letter of jude quote directly from 1 enoch 1 book of the watchers, but the entire letter and its alternate version in 2 peter show signs of literary and theological dependency on the rest of the book of the watchers chaps.
Why is the book of enoch not included in the bible. Enoch, the seventh from adam, prophesied, saying, behold, the lord came with ten thousands of his holy ones. It was considered scripture by many early christians. If his enemies were citing 1 enoch, jude may be using their own book against them. In fact, enoch is a collection of several books, written over. The book of enoch 3 introduction i have based this book on michael a. The book of enoch was considered as scripture in the epistle of barnabas 16. To execute judgment upon all, and to convince all that are ungodly among them of all their ungodly deeds which they have ungodly committed, and of all their hard speeches which ungodly sinners have spoken against him. The only people who accept the book as an official part of their holy scriptures are ethiopian jews and the ethiopian orthodox church and a few more obscure religious groups around the. Behold, he comes with ten thousands of his saints, to execute judgment upon them, and destroy the wicked, and reprove all the carnal for everything which the sinful and ungodly have done, and committed against him. And enoch also, the seventh from adam, prophesied of these, saying, behold, the lord cometh with ten thousands of his.
366 265 90 1533 1366 839 1426 756 1077 997 540 1195 415 314 1302 423 321 1067 1195 12 314 1271 1461 192 1303 745 531 252 1050 254 281 898 820 556 1241 503 971 730 1287 413 704 94 544 844 12